Centers Don't Help Men
Special Fathers Day 1998 statement by Philip Cook
Author of "Abused Men: The Hidden Side of Domestic Violence"
spent hours calling, saying 'This is what happened. The police refuse
to take a report. I need a restraining order. How can I get her arrested?'
They said, 'Well, we don't know what to say to a man.' Or, "Well, we
just help women.'"
Stanley Green's experience is typical of men physically abused by their
wives who attempt to call domestic violence shelters. Green says he
suffered years of abuse and finally decided to seek help after a beating
in a car. While he was in his seat belt, his wife allegedly used a cell
phone to hit him and then jumped on him and kicked him, resulting in
a fractured rib and numerous other injuries. Most abused men however,
don't bother calling shelters or domestic violence crisis lines because
they rightly assume they won't get help. If they knew that domestic
violence shelters and crisis lines would not discriminate and treat
men fairly, they would call. Minister Joe Cogan, after police allegedly
failed to arrest his wife for throwing a knife at him and cutting him
the shoulder, says he "very definitely" would have called such a service:
"It seems as though I had no one to really turn to. To say, you know,
'How can I cope with this?' I felt as though I was out in a boat in
the ocean all by myself. I saw so many opportunities for help for women
in my situation. I don't deny them that opportunity, but the other side
is, I felt I had been an abused husband, and an abused parent, with
really nowhere to turn."
Green sums up the situation facing male victims of domestic violence:
"I don't know of any state in the nation where it's legal for an agency
that accepts government funds to discriminate on the basis of sex. Maybe
you could argue for a separate but equal basis, though that's a very
tenuous argument, too. How can a feminist, or anyone, argue for sex
discrimination? Yet that's exactly what's going on in shelters and crisis
lines across the country."
Opponents of gender neutral services or language say it is too difficult
to provide services for both sexes, but in fact, there are a few shelters
like the Valley Oasis Crisis Center in Lancaster, California that easily
accommodate both genders without conflict. In Charlottesville, Virginia
and Kelso, Washington for example, gender neutral crisis lines do not
provide on site shelter, but do help arrange transitional housing and
discount hotel rooms, as well as provide traditional counseling, court
advocacy and some support groups. Any existing shelter or crisis line
could help males with these types of services, but discrimination and
often outright hostility towards the male victim is the norm.
When Erin Pizzey opened the world's first shelter for battered women
in 1972, and wrote the first modern book on domestic violence, "Scream
Quietly, or the Neighbors Will Hear" in 1974, government, police, and
the news media predicted that her shelter would stand empty. No one
would come, because these women were so few in number and were being
adequately served by exiting institutions. Pizzey's shelter of course,
and others that followed were soon filled to overflowing. The same situation
exists for men today, with the important difference that an even larger
entrenched structure has successfully denied services to victims. Pizzey
herself understands this: "For the last twenty-five years, a powerful
women's movement, has managed to silence anyone who dare question their
mis-appropriation of funds and their refusal to accept that millions
of men have been denied their legal rights."
The Federal Violence Against Women Act with it's emphasis on providing
large amounts of taxpayer dollars for women-only domestic violence services
aids the current sex discrimination and denial of services. In fact,
funds are being used not only to discriminate in provision of services,
but also to promote the idea that men don't need the services! It is
also quite plainly, a violation of the 14th. amendment's equal protection
Even with over forty published studies, (many funded by government arms
like the National Institute of Mental Health), conclusively proving
that domestic violence has a large number of male victims, and the same
sources used in government hearings to show the incidence of female
victims, there are few politicians courageous enough to vote against
the VAWA act, or even give its funding criteria the kind of scrutiny
routinely given to other programs. The unprecedented government legalized
and richly funded sex discrimination continues. Erin Pizzey says it
should come as no surprise: "Most of the shelters aren't there to help
women come to terms with what is happening in their lives. They are
there to fund their conferences and their statements against men."
This may be a bit of an overstatement on Pizzey's part (but then her
home was shot at by advocates who wanted to silence her) as there are
many shelters that do care and provide excellent services for women
victims. However, anyone who wants to change things faces an uphill
battle, as Janis Dimmitt the Executive Director of the Kelso, Washington
Emergency Shelter explains: "The road to enlightenment has been a rocky
one. We are looked upon as being friends of the perpetrators rather
than friends of the victims, because all males are supposed to be evil
and bad. This attitude prevails in many shelters."
According to reports from thousands of women in violent relationships
current government policy and services are based on only half the truth,
as they report that half the time they hit first, and a quarter of the
time, only they were violent.
If Pizzey and others are right, powerful forces are intent in keeping
the the truth about domestic violence hidden. It will take attorneys
and politicians with uncommon courage willing to challenge these forces
in order to establish fair and equitable programs that will in the end
provide more meaningful results in the battle against domestic violence
for women, children, and men.
Philip W. Cook is the author of Abused Men-The
Hidden Side of Domestic Violence (Praeger). He frequently lectures on
the subject around the U.S. and has appeared on "Sally," the "Crier
Report, " "MSNBC" and other nationally broadcast programs. He can be
contacted at PO Box 951 Tualatin, OR 97062. or through the web site
at: www.abusedmen.com .